Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?

Updated 20 Nov 20262 sources
Quick answer

Spare Arnold in the early Hey Arnold mission: he swims off and much later pays you a $10,000 bonus, while killing him gets you nothing extra.

Low-angle shot of Lucia and Jason holding pistols in a dim, teal-lit stairwell under a fluorescent light
Image: Rockstar Games

This choice comes up early in the game during the main story mission Hey Arnold. After the argument turns ugly, Jason chases Arnold onto a pier and corners him at the far end. Arnold drops to his knees and begs, and at that point the game asks you to decide his fate.

What each choice does

  • Kill Arnold: he dies on the pier and the matter is closed. You lose out on the cash bonus that comes later.
  • Spare Arnold: he swims away and you will not hear from him for a long time. When he finally gets back in touch, he hands you $10,000 as thanks for letting him live.

How to do it

  1. Play the main story mission Hey Arnold.
  2. Chase Arnold down with Jason after the confrontation.
  3. Corner him at the end of the pier.
  4. When the choice prompt appears, pick the option to spare him.
  5. Keep playing the story, and the $10,000 reward will arrive much later.

The payout takes a while, so do not worry if nothing happens right away.

Other decisions in the story: every GTA 6 choice and what it changes.

Seen this in your game?

Send us a screenshot of this from your own game. We check it and show it on this page with your name, so other players know the guide works.

Send a screenshot in Telegram

Found something different in the game? Write to [email protected] with a screenshot, and we will check it against our sources and update this page.